Opening Section Review
Improve your work-in-progress with expert editorial feedback
One of the biggest challenges writers face is knowing whether their writing is working or not. The best way to remedy this is with impartial feedback from someone who knows what they’re talking about. Our opening section review offers expert feedback on the opening 20,000 words of your manuscript. It is ideal for first-time writers needing guidance, as well as experienced writers who want a sense-check on their works-in-progress.
Jericho Writers was founded by writers, for writers. Four of us are published by the Big 5, while others are deep in the writing process. We carefully select the editors and agents we work with — we choose the kind of people we’d want to guide us in our own writing. It’s this approach that has helped authors move forward with confidence, launch their careers, sign with literary agents and become Sunday Times bestsellers.
What can you expect from a opening section review?
An opening section review gives you expert feedback on the first 20,000 words of your manuscript. Your editor will provide a detailed 2,000-word report focusing on structure, pace, dialogue, voice and style, characterisation, and commercial potential. They’ll highlight what’s working in your writing and help you address areas that may need improvement.
This service is perfect for authors who want professional advice on their opening chapters to ensure they’re on the right track. It can also be used to assess the commercial viability of your book idea.
If you’re seeking advice on more than 20,000 words, you’ll need a manuscript assessment. If you’d benefit from feedback on your early chapters and would also like advice on how you’re pitching your book to agents, then an agent submission pack review would be the most suitable service for you.
Your opening section review will include
Download a sample report to see what your opening section review will look like.
Actionable feedback on 20,000 words
Advice on commercial potential
Discussion with your editor
Get personalised support from a professional book editor
We’ve worked hard over 20 years to hand-pick our team of expert editors. Once you buy an opening section review, you can request your dream editor or let our Writer Support Team match you with the editor that best fits your work. Our book editors specialise in trade fiction and non-fiction texts. They include traditionally published authors as well as publishing professionals such as literary agents and Big 5 publishers.
Kesia Lupo
Commissioning editor at Pan Macmillan Children’s
- Bio
- Books
- Genres
Kesia Lupo is currently a Commissioning Editor at Macmillan Children’s UK and a former literary agent at Donald Maass Literary Agency representing children’s fiction, adult fiction and select adult non-fiction. Her 11 years experience in publishing makes her a valuable editor who will expertly advise you on your submission pack to elevate your materials and help you improve your chances with agents.
She has worked with both UK and US based authors, and so is uniquely positioned to answer any questions you may have on the market in either location.
- Contemporary
- Crime/Thriller/Action
- Fantasy
- Historical
- Literary (including Bookclub)
- Paranormal
- Science Fiction
- Romance/erotica
- Women’s
- Young Adult
Rebecca Roy
Former commissioning editor at Little Brown
- Bio
- Books
- Genres
Rebecca has over ten years’ experience in the publishing industry, commissioning commercial fiction for the UK’s leading publishing houses, including Little Brown, Simon & Schuster and Bonnier Books.
Rebecca’s editorial experience is vast, and she has edited fiction across all commercial genres, but her particular editorial specialties are romance, historical, crime and thriller.
You can find some of Rebecca’s clients on the ‘books’ tab.
- Contemporary
- Crime/Thriller
- Historical
- Literary (including Bookclub)
- Romance/Erotica
- Women’s
Richard Roper
Former commissioning editor at Headline
- Bio
- Genres
Richard is an author and experienced editor, having worked as a senior commissioning editor for non-fiction at Headline (part of Hachette UK), where he published several Sunday Times bestsellers.
Richard gives the perspective of a publisher, an author, and an editor. His knowledge of the publishing business make his insight on marketability and commercial appeal invaluable. Richard is thorough, upbeat, and incisive in his reports. Whether you’re writing nonfiction or commercial fiction, you’ll be in safe hands with him.
- Comic/satire
- Contemporary
- Memoir/autobiography
- Other narrative non-fiction
- Short stories and novellas
- Subject-led non-fiction
- Women’s
Holly Seddon
Internationally bestselling author
- Bio
- Books
- Genres
Holly is an international bestselling author with six published novels to date. She is also a mentor and tutor on our Ultimate Novel Writing Course.
Holly is endlessly supportive and encouraging of every writer we send her way. We love her concise and on-point editorial style.
- Contemporary
- Crime/Thriller/Action
- Literary (including Bookclub)
- Plays and screen scripts
- Short stories and novellas
- Women’s
Megan Carroll
Literary agent at Watson, Little Ltd
- Bio
- Genres
Megan Carroll is a literary agent at Watson, Little Ltd with over a decade of experience in the industry. Her tastes span many genres and Megan is keen to read anything across women’s fiction – including novels in the romance, book club and upmarket space – YA, and MG. In her 11 years at the agency, she has read or worked on almost every type of fiction and non-fiction project and is open to looking at everything.
She brings her market experience as an agent to her editorial work and loves discussing pace, themes, dialogue and voice with a particular focus on plot and ensuring that there’s a clear hook to get attention from an agent. editor and eventual reader.
- Contemporary
- Literary (including Book Club)
- Women’s
- Historical
- Fantasy
- Paranormal
- Memoir/autobiography
- Narrative non-fiction
- Picture books
- Children’s
- Young Adult
- Romance & erotica
Why choose Jericho Writers?
Many companies promise to get your book published, but we only offer services we believe will genuinely benefit you. Unsure if this is the right fit? Book a call with us – we’ll be honest with you. This commitment to integrity has helped Jericho Writers thrive for over 20 years.
Don’t take just our word for it…
We’ve been helping writers achieve their goals for over 20 years. Here’s what some of them had to say about our editorial services:
You kindly gave me some excellent feedback on the initial stages of my novel. Well, it’s “finished”, and I have been fortunate to have it shortlisted for the Wilbur Smith Foundation Award for Adventure novel of the year (unpublished).
Richard F
Opening Section Review client
Your comments on the random points of view in my opening paragraph left me stunned! I take all your advice gratefully, and all of the technical points like POV, tense, dialogue, etc., went straight on the to do list.
Steve K
Opening Section Review client
Thank you again for your encouragement and many brilliant suggestions for my Cuba novel. I found them very perceptive and incorporated them into another draft.
Marion D
Opening Section Review client
Thank you so much for thorough feedback, kind words and encouragement. It means a lot. I found your report very clear and it sparked many ideas
Aman K
Editorial client
I remain impressed by both the quality and the quantity of Liz’s work. Apart from the overall comments, she goes into such great detail, character by character, chapter by chapter, missing nothing.
Carmella A
Editorial client
I was also blown away with your encouragement and thoughtfulness. You have given me excellent advice on how to focus on not only the query and synopsis, but also the plot. I encourage other writers to use your service.
Milo P
Agent Submission Pack Review client
Thank you for your perceptive and incisive report. I’ve been desperate for help like this and so much wish that I had found Jericho Writers a few years ago.
Richard F
Editorial client
Very happy with the editing notes, it was just what I’d hoped for to move forward with my manuscript.
Helen V
Opening Section Review client
Kate [Rizzo]’s comments were very helpful. She made several suggestions for improvements which make sense. I can see how they would improve the narrative, especially in terms of characterisation and pacing. I am working my way through implementing them.
Adrienne T
Opening Section Review client
Could you be our next success story?
Over the last 20 years, many of our clients have gone on to win prizes, become bestsellers, get film and TV deals, achieve huge global sales, and more. To name a few, John David Mann went onto become a New York Times Bestselling author; Paul Braddon’s The Actuality has been optioned for a TV series; Eleanor Anstruther won the Desmond Elliott prize; and Nussaibah Younis has been shortlisted for The Women’s Prize awards. Now it’s your turn.
Claire Hatcher-Smith
Published by Farshore (HarperCollins)
R.S. Burnett
The Sunday Times’ best thrillers of 2025
S.J. King
Two book deal with Storm Publishing
Nussaibah Younis
Shortlisted for The Women’s Prize 2025
Anna Mazzola
Won the Edgar Allen Poe Award for Best Paperback in 2018
Adrienne Chinn
Two book deal from Avon Books
Dominic Brownlow
Published by Louise Walters Books
M.J. Camilleri
2023 Page Turner Writing Award finalist
Dr Martyn Pritchard
Published by Troubadour
Ian Siragher
Published by The Book Guild
T. E. Mountain
Published by The Book Guild
L. C. Scott
Successfully self-published
Jane Loftus
Two book deal with HQ Digital
L. M. West
Successfully self-published
Angela Gabriela Horne
Successfully self-published
Helen Graham
Published by Troubadour
Aneeta Sundararaj
Published by Penguin Random House SEA
John Mullins
Published by Troubadour Publishing
Rosie Radcliffe
Published by The Book Guild
C A Sole
4.5 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Shelley Dark
Successfully self-published and now bestselling
Elizabeth Delo
Shortlisted for the debut novel prize at the ‘Festival du Premier Roman’ in Chambéry
Elizabeth Kuliogowski
Shortlisted for the Women’s Prize Discoveries Award
Trish McGarrahan
4.8 star rating on Amazon.com
Alison Robinson
Published by Village Editorial
Jack Chandler
Amazon bestseller
Stella Darvey Joory
Published by Troubador
Eleanor Burney
Top 100 in the Bath Novel Award 2025
Carys Shannon
Published by Parthian Books
Dr. Thaier Alhusain
Amazon bestseller
Jim O’Sullivan
Published by Rymour Books
Grant Ennis
Published by Daraja Press
Susie Violet
4.3 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Wendy Sacks Jones
Shortlisted for the Mslexia Novel, Virginia Prize for Fiction and Exeter Novel awards
G. J. Jilia
5.0 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Hastie Salih
Published by Troubador
Milla Reed
Featured in the October issue of Prima Magazine
Steven Pashko
5.0 star rating on Amazon.com
Jeremy Gray
Published by Troubador
Tracy Cook
Will be published by Allison and BusbyT
Chris Cutler
5.0 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Kathleen Mayes
4.4 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Joanna Howat
4.0 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Chris Mabey
Published by Penguin Random House SEA
Liz Foster
Published by Affirm Press (Simon & Schuster AU)
R. D. Holmes
4.6 star rating on Amazon.co.uk
Kate MacDougall
Published by Bonnier
J Herman Kleiger
International Book Award recipient
Beth Williams
Amazon UK Bestseller
Colin Duncan Taylor
Will be published by Yale University Press
Dr Venetia Constantine
Instant Sunday Times bestseller
Clíodhna O’Sullivan
No.1 International Bestseller
Get actionable, expert feedback on your work in as little as two weeks
OPENING SECTION REVIEW
Need more info before you decide?
Choosing the right service for your work is hard. But we’re on hand to help! Book a call with our Writer Support team at a time to suit you to talk through the options.
Frequently asked
questions
Who will be giving the feedback?
An editor who best suits your editorial content. We match manuscripts based on 15 years of experience working with our editors. We consider editor experience, their genres of interest, and whether they themselves feel they are the right fit for your work. As all our editors are freelance, this depends on availability.
Can I contact the editor directly?
No, but their in-depth report will contain actionable advice for you to progress with your manuscript.
How long does it take?
The turnaround is usually three to four weeks.
What genres do you accept?
All trade fiction and non-fiction. We are not suited to edit academic texts.
Do I need to be based in the UK for this service?
Not at all, our editorial services are delivered online and are suitable for writers from all around the world.
Can you help me find an agent?
Yes, you can log onto Jericho Writers’ AgentMatch, our database of over 1,000 UK and US literary agents.
Not the right service for you?
Whether you’re looking for detailed structural edits, line-editing, or your just getting started and need some feedback on your opening chapters. We have you covered.