Short Story Review: get insightful & actionable feedback – Jericho Writers
Jericho Writers
167-169 Great Portland street, 5th Floor, London, W1W 5PF
UK: +44 (0)330 043 0150
US: +1 (646) 974 9060
Perfect for authors with a finished draft

Short Story Review

From £250
Get detailed editorial advice on your short story or short stories collection from a professional editor.
1-2 week turnaround time

Get expert feedback on your short stories

An expert editor will assess your manuscript, providing feedback and advice on style, structure, pacing, characterisation, and more, alongside basic spelling, grammar, and punctuation. They will offer support in tackling the next steps and addressing problem areas, with the option to discuss the report directly with the editor. Each story will be looked at individually and addressed separately. Where appropriate, stories will also be considered as part of a collection, for example considering how they work together and their overall presentation.

Could you be our next success story?

We’ve helped hundreds of writers like you get published. Many of our clients have gone on to win prizes, become bestsellers, get film deals, achieve huge global sales, and more. Now it’s your turn.

What’s included?

Whether you choose the express or regular service, you’ll receive:

Actionable feedback on your short stories

An expert editor will assess up to 50,000 words of your short stories/collection, providing feedback and advice on style, structure, pacing, characterisation, and more.

Commercial potential

Your expert editor will assess the commercial viability of your work, whether you are entering competitions, submitting to magazines, journals, or anthologies, or publishing a collection of short stories.

Support tackling next steps

The short story review will cover what works well and what needs addressing. Your editor will give you clear steps to follow to resolve problem areas, with examples.

Detailed editorial report

For short story reviews, editorial reports range from 1500 to 2500 words, depending on the wordcount submitted.

Discussion with your editor

After you receive your short story review, you’ll have the opportunity to clarify anything you’re unsure of with your editor via email before you begin polishing your work.

Need more support?

If you’d like to continue to work with your editor after you have received your editorial report, you can book one-on-one mentoring.

Why choose us?

There are lots of companies promising you the dream of getting your short stories published. We value ourselves on only ever selling you a service that we think will benefit you. Not sure if this one is right for you? Give us a call, we’d love to hear from you. If we don’t think this service is right for you, we’ll tell you – honestly. This is one of the many values we hold that have helped us run Jericho Writers successfully for over 20 years.

Jericho Writers Short Story Review

What’s included in our short story review service?

Other Popular Providers

Express Service available
Feedback on entire short story collection
Feedback on commercial potential
Detailed editorial report
1,500 to 2,500 word report
2 page summary
Work with a professional book editor
Opportunity to ask follow-up questions directly with your editor
Opportunity to book additional mentoring sessions with your editor

Want to see exactly what you’ll receive from an editor?

Your short story review will provide you with the same quality report as a manuscript assessment.

GET FEEDBACK TO IMPROVE YOUR WORK IN AS LITTLE AS ONE WEEK

Improve your short stories with expert feedback

Most Popular!
£250.00

SHORT STORY REVIEW

Get an editorial report on up to a 50,000 word collection of short stories
Receive actionable feedback that will elevate your work
Discuss your report with your editor over email
Receive your report in two weeks
Please note, during busy periods turnaround times may be extended
Premium Members enjoy a 10% discount
£350.00

EXPRESS SHORT STORY REVIEW

Want to get to work improving your writing as soon as possible?
Our express service gives you everything in a normal Short Story Review, but quicker
Receive your report in one week
Discuss your report with your editor over email
Premium Members enjoy a 10% discount

Need more info before you decide?

Choosing the right service for your work is hard. But we’re on hand to help! Book a call with our Writer Support team at a time to suit you to talk through the options.

Our Short Story Editors

Request your dream editor or let our team match you with the editor best suited to your work. We’ve hand-selected our team of expert book editors over the last 20 years, including specialists across trade fiction and non-fiction. Here you’ll find traditionally published authors as well as publishing professionals such as literary agents and editors with Big 5 publisher experience.

Previous
Dexter Petley

Dexter Petley

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Dexter Petley is an experienced editor, acclaimed literary novelist, memoirist and translator. As a long serving editor with Jericho Writers, (since 2005) many of Dexter’s clients have achieved considerable success in finding agents and publishers.

 

Dexter does not shy away from complex themes or influences. His expertise spans entire genres, from commercial book club to war fiction. He takes everything in his stride, turning his fastidious, but fair, eye to anything at hand – making you a better writer for it.

Previous
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary (Including ‘bookclub’)
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Historical fiction
  • Women’s fiction
  • Comic/Satire
  • Young Adult
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Memoir/autobiography
  • Narrative Non-fiction
  • Subject-led Non-fiction
Vee Walker

Vee Walker

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Love of family history was the start point for Vee Walker’s unique debut novel Major Tom’s War (Kashi House), which evolved from a non-fiction account of an unlikely WWI courtship into gripping historical fiction.

 

Working in both fiction and non-fiction, Vee honed her writing/editing skills as a heritage consultant for 20+ years at museums and natural/historic sites throughout the UK. Her poetry and descriptive writing can be found within unusual interpretive installations on mountains, in forests and along the coast.

Previous
majortomswar
Next
  • Historical
  • Contemporary
  • Literary (Including ‘bookclub’)
  • Women’s
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Fantasy
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Comic/Satire
  • Picture books
  • Children’s
  • Memoir/autobiography
  • Narrative Non-fiction
Louise Tondeur

Louise Tondeur

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Louise Tondeur writes fiction, poetry, plays and nonfiction and has supported countless writers with her feedback. Her first novels, The Water’s Edge and The Haven Home for Delinquent Girls, were published with Headline Review. Louise has also published a short story collection and multiple works of nonfiction.

 

Louise studied a Creative Writing MA at the University of East Anglia, followed by a PhD at the University of Reading. In addition to working on her own writing, Louise works as a Creative Writing lecturer.

Previous
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Womenn’s
  • Romance/Erotica
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Comic/Satire
  • Paranormal
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Narrative Non-Fiction
  • Subject-led Non-Fiction
Sharon Zink

Sharon Zink

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres
  • Awards

Dr Sharon Zink studied English Literature at London and Cambridge, and has over eleven years of experience editing and teaching creative writing. She reads widely and is perfect for adult novels that fall between genres.

 

Her first novel, Welcome to Sharonville (Unthank Books, 2014), was longlisted for The Guardian First Book Award and is currently being developed as a TV series. She has won numerous awards, including Young Poet of the Year and Writers Inc. Writer of the Year, and has been shortlisted three times for The New Writer Short Story Award and The Raymond Carver Prize.

Previous
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Women’s
  • Romance/Erotica
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Comic/Satire
  • Short Story/Novellas
  • Young Adult
  • Memoir/Autobiography
  • Narrative Non-Fiction
  • Shell Young Poet of the Year
  • Writers Inc. Writer of the Year
Liz Monument

Liz Monument

Editor/Tutor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Liz Monument writes all kinds of fiction, including SF, historical, and horror. Her debut novel The Eternity Fund was shortlisted for Mslexia’s unpublished novel competition in 2013 and was published by Fahrenheit Press in 2015. Her second novel Iteration was on the submissions list for the Arthur C Clarke Award in 2018.

 

Liz is a tutor on our Ultimate Novel Writing Course and is particularly brilliant for writers who want an Australian perspective on their work, plus those writing historical fiction and dystopian/science fiction.

Previous
Liz Monument Iteration
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Women’s
  • Romance/Erotica
  • Women’s
  • Comic/Satire
  • Historical
  • Young Adult
  • Memoir/Autobiography
  • Narrative Non-Fiction
  • Subject-Led Non-Fiction
Gideon Roberton

Gideon Roberton

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Gideon is an experienced editor, story analyst and a published author. Under the pen name Gideon Saint, he writes the Amazon best-selling Drake’s War series of WW2 spy thrillers. Gideon previously worked for Twentieth Century Fox, Focus Features, and Universal Pictures International as a story analyst, and ran a department of a trade publishing business in London for a number of years.

 

Gideon has an MA and MFA in Creative Writing, and has also studied Screenwriting and Contemporary Media Practice. Having been on all sides of the table, he is uniquely placed to support aspiring authors and screenwriters.

Previous
Drake's War Book Cover
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Historical
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Comic/Satire
  • Paranormal
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Plays/Screen Scripts
  • Memoir/Autobiography
Clare Harvey

Clare Harvey

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Clare Harvey is the acclaimed author of four historical fiction novels published by Simon & Schuster (UK). Clare has a background in journalism (print and radio), charity PR, copywriting, and English tuition. Clare has lived and worked all over the world but now lives in Nottingham with her family and is working towards her creative writing PhD at Coventry University.

 

As both an incredibly accomplished editor and sharp-minded reader, she possesses the skill to focus on the root of a problem and provide actionable advice in a clear and compassionate manner.

Previous
Next
  • Historical
  • Women’s
  • Short Stories/Novellas
Emma Norry

Emma Norry

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Writing middle-grade and young adult books as E.L Norry, Em made her debut in 2019 with Son of the Circus (Scholastic), a Victorian historical story published in the VOICES series. She has also written a biography of Nelson Mandela (Puffin) and a standalone upper MG contemporary action-adventure book.

 

Em has had short stories published in the collection Home Again: Stories about Coming Home from War (Scholastic) and in three anthologies: Happy Here (Knights Of), The Place for Me: Stories from the Windrush (Scholastic) and A Very Merry Murder Club (Farshore).

Previous
Next
  • Children’s
  • Young Adult
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Contemporary
  • Plays/Screen Script
Katy Massey

Katy Massey

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

Katy was a journalist for 15 years before studying for an MA and PhD in Creative Writing from Newcastle University. Katy has worked extensively as a mentor and publisher of over 50 novice writers across two anthologies: Tangled Roots and Who Are We Now?

 

Her memoir, Are We Home Yet? (Jacaranda Books) was published in 2020 and shortlisted for the Jhalak Prize and the Portico Prize. In addition, her fiction and nonfiction has been widely anthologised, including Common People edited by Kit de Waal from Unbound, The Place for Me, published by Scholastic, and upcoming speculative collection Glimpse, from Peepal Tree Press.

Previous
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Women’s
  • Historical
  • Comic/Satire
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Young Adult
  • Memoir/Autobiography
  • Narrative Non-Fiction
  • Subject-Led Non-Fiction
Pauline Kiernan

Pauline Kiernan

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres
  • Awards

Dr Pauline Frederica Kiernan is an award-winning playwright, screenwriter and short story writer, with over 12 years experience as a literary, theatre and film consultant. She has taught Creative Writing at undergraduate and MA levels at Oxford University, and was appointed Leverhulme Fellowship at Shakespeare’s Globe.

 

She is the author of Screenwriting They Can’t Resist: How to Create Screenplays of Originality and Cinematic Power. Break The Rules. Her monographs, Shakespeare’s Theory of Drama, and Staging Shakespeare at the New Globe were published to worldwide acclaim, and her best-selling Filthy Shakespeare: Shakespeare’s Most Outrageous Sexual Puns was an Observer Book of the Year. She is currently writing the first of a series of crime novels set in Italy.

Previous
Next
  • Short Story/Novella
  • Plays/Screen Scripts
  • Literary
  • Memoir/Autobiography
  • Narrative Non-Fiction
  • Observer Book of the Year
Sibyl Ruth

Sibyl Ruth

Editor

  • Bio
  • Books
  • Genres

An experienced teacher and mentor, Sibyl has worked with authors who have have gone on to win literary prizes and awards. Her short fiction and creative non-fiction have appeared in multiple magazines and e-zines. Her poems have also been widely anthologised and broadcast and she has been Birmingham Poet Laureate.

 

After studying English at Cambridge, Sibyl Ruth went on to publish two small press collections of poetry and win the Mslexia Poetry Competition. She has also scripted and presented two features for Radio 4: Listen to Them Breathing and Terezin Dreams.

Previous
Next
  • Contemporary
  • Literary
  • Crime/Thriller
  • Women’s
  • Comic/Satire
  • Young Adult
  • Memoir/Autobiography
  • Short Story/Novella
Next

Frequently asked
questions

1

Do I need to be based in the UK for this service? 

Not at all! Our editorial services are delivered online and are suitable for writers from all around the world. 

2

How do I submit my short stories? 

Do you have a short story in need of a professional set of eyes? Here are the steps to follow to submit your short stories for our professional editing service: 

1) Select your word count in the box above (choose the one that matches your project’s total word count).

2) Click on “Add to basket” 

3) Once you’ve made your payment, you’ll be sent an email with a link. Click on this and you’ll be able to upload your manuscript for review.

3

How should I format my manuscript? 

Please only upload Word documents via the online submission form. Don’t forget to number your pages and double space your lines, and use an easy-to-read font like Times New Roman 12.  

It’s also helpful for our editors if you make sure paragraphs are indented and use page breaks where needed throughout your manuscript. 

4

How do you choose the editor? 

We match manuscripts based on over 20 years of experience working with our editors. We consider editor experience, their genres of interest, and whether they themselves feel they are the right fit for your work. All matches depend on editors’ availability.   

5

Can I choose my editor? 

If you have a particular editor in mind, we will of course do our best to match you with them. We cannot guarantee this, however, as all of our editors are freelance and there are times when they are unavailable due to demand and/or other commitments. 

Once you have placed your order, you’re welcome to send a shortlist of 4-5 editors from our website. We’ll do our best to place you with one of your preferred choices. 

6

How long will it take to match my manuscript with an editor? 

We aim to match you with the right editor within 2-4 days. We’ll get back to you as soon as the choice has been confirmed. 

7

How long does it take to receive my editorial report? 

If you’ve ordered a standard editorial report, you can expect our team to deliver this around two weeks after they receive your manuscript.  

Express reports can be delivered in as little as one week. 

8

Will I be able to discuss my report with my editor? 

Following your editorial report, there will be an opportunity to check in with your editor via email. At this stage, you are welcome to ask a few follow-up questions regarding your editorial report.

If you’d like to continue working with your editor on your short story, you could consider one-to-one mentoring. These are flexible, online sessions that can be tailored to your needs. Find out more about Mentoring here or get in touch with our Writer Support team. 

9

Do the short stories need to be connected (e.g. from one collection)? 

Your short stories do not need to be connected, though it would be useful to include this information in your submissions form. For example, if your short stories are connected and you would like the editor to give feedback on how they work together, let us know. If your stories are not connected and you would like them to each one to be considered individually, that’s fine too, just make sure to include this information.