Writing Dark Themes in Your Novel (Without Losing Your Mind)

Let’s talk about dark stuff.

You know… secrets, trauma, murder, toxic relationships, betrayal, obsession, grief, manipulation, psychological warfare disguised as small talk over coffee.

Fun, right?

If you’re writing thrillers, crime, horror, dark romance, or anything remotely gritty, dark themes come with the territory. But writing them well? That’s a whole different skill set. Anyone can throw a dead body into chapter one. Not everyone can make readers feel something while they’re reading it.

So let’s break it down.

Dark doesn’t mean miserable

There’s a big difference between dark and depressing.

Dark themes work best when they’re balanced with moments of normalcy, humour, warmth, or hope. Think contrast. A tense interrogation scene hits harder when it follows a cozy family dinner. A shocking betrayal feels sharper if you’ve just watched the characters laugh together.

Real life isn’t wall-to-wall trauma. Neither should your novel be. Give your readers breathing room. (And give yourself some too.)

Make it emotional, not just graphic

Here’s a common mistake: equating dark with violent.

You don’t need to describe every drop of blood or every gruesome detail to make something unsettling. Often, what isn’t shown is far creepier than what is. I always like to use horror movies as an example. Now, sure, there are people who LOVE movies where every limb being chopped off is shown in graphic detail. (I’m not one of those people, but you do you.) What I find scarier is movies where the scary thing is hidden. I know it’s there. The music, the atmosphere, the lighting etc all tell me there is something bloody terrifying about to happen, but what happens in my mind is WAY scarier than anything that could be shown on screen. It’s the same with books.

If you’re purposefully writing gory fiction, fine. There’s a market for that. But if you’re leaning more into the commercial fiction side and want to appeal to as many readers as possible, instead of focusing on gore, focus on:

• How the character feels
• What they’re afraid of
• What they’re losing
• What this moment changes for them

Emotional darkness sticks longer than shock value. Psychological damage > splatter scenes. Every time.

Let your characters carry the weight

Dark themes work when they’re personal.

Readers connect to people, not concepts. So instead of “this town has a dark past,” show us how that past ruined someone’s marriage. Instead of “she survived trauma,” show us how she flinches when someone raises their voice. Let your characters embody the darkness. That’s where the power lives.

Don’t romanticize the bad stuff

If you’re writing about abuse, addiction, manipulation, or violence, be mindful of how you frame it.

You don’t need to preach. But you also don’t want to accidentally glamorize something destructive unless that’s part of the story (and even then, there should usually be consequences). Dark themes feel more real when they’re messy and complicated, not aestheticized into something shiny. Toxic is toxic, even if he’s tall and broody.

Use darkness to reveal truth

The best dark moments aren’t there just to be edgy. They reveal character. They expose secrets. They force decisions. They strip away masks.

Ask yourself:

• What does this dark moment change?
• What does it reveal?
• Who becomes someone new because of it?

If the answer is “nothing,” the scene probably doesn’t need to exist.

Protect your own mental health (seriously)

My darkest novel is The Woman In The Cabin. It’s also my bestselling novel (just goes to show, readers love darkness!). But I didn’t write that book in a healthy way. I spent way too much time with the darkness inside those pages. It became all consuming. By the time I finished writing it, I was exhausted, miserable, and found myself all-consumed by the bad in the world. It’s no coincidence that my next book was called a ‘popcorn thriller’ and reviews said it was ‘not as dark as The Woman In The Cabin’. I literally wasn’t capable of doing it again!

Writing dark material can mess with your head. You’re spending hours inside imaginary trauma, after all.

So:

• Take breaks
• Watch something light after heavy writing sessions
• Move your body
• Talk to real humans
• Don’t binge-write murder scenes at midnight for three days straight (Ask me how I know.)

You’re allowed to care for yourself while creating heavy stories.

Remember: Readers love the dark… when it’s done well

People don’t pick up dark novels because they want to feel awful. They pick them up because they want to feel something. They want intensity. Catharsis. Suspense. Emotional payoff. They want to explore scary or painful ideas safely through fiction.

Your job isn’t to traumatize your reader. It’s to take them on a journey they won’t forget.

Now go ruin someone’s fictional life.

Our expert tutors are here to guide you, whether it’s building heart-stopping suspense, crafting complex characters, or mastering the art of the twist. Take your crime and thriller writing to the next level with our expert tutors. Work one-to-one with thriller author Megan Collins on the Ultimate Novel Writing Programme, or join crime author Graham on our six-week Crime & Thriller course to master suspense, plot twists, and red herrings.