Literary agent and co-founder of Selby Howard Literary Agency, Jon Curzon, joins us to share his keen insights into the most important questions for authors to ask when an agent is offering representation. This all-important call is an exciting moment but Jon draws on his experience of being an agent from over a decade to give his top tips for approaching this.
So, you’ve done it. You perfected your query letter, submitted your opening chapters and your synopsis (likely to more than a few agents…), had a request for the full manuscript, and now the agent wants to talk.
This is obviously a very exciting but understandably nerve-wracking part of the process for querying authors, a stage that is key in shaping how these early conversations can then cement the agent-author relationship going forward.
Firstly, as an agent I’d say meeting in person is best – though considerations like geography and schedules can come into this – and if this isn’t possible a Zoom is always constructive. It helps to see each other and connect in this way. Secondly, I’d say that although the dynamics could feel one-sided, you are really auditioning each other, and as an author you should feel confident approaching this call as an equal partner.
After all, where would agents be without authors?
In my conversations with potential clients, it’s always positive to be asked some of the following questions:
How hands-on are you editorially?
Agents might vary in how much editorial input they have, but generally it depends on what stage the manuscript is at. Some agents have readers that help them in this process; some work closely and directly. It’s more to gauge, in discussion here, how they edit: is it a round of edits and a short report and then send it back to me in x months? Is it let’s check in weekly on progress and points? Is the agent quite direct and cut-throat in editing, or is it a softer approach? Again, as much as there’s no wrong answer, there’s no wrong question – it’s all good to get out there in the initial meeting.
What is the timeline?
Really, this is probably the first and foremost question on authors’ minds. As agents we totally understand that news stories of overnight pre-empts are exciting, but these tend to be the exception, not the rule. You can come to the conversation with some idea of these key terms (like pre-empt or auction), though the main question to ask in this respect is: what do you imagine the timeline being?
Get professional feedback on your book outline
Get expert advice on your book outline before you get stuck into the writing. We’ll give you a 1,500-word report on what’s working and what’s not.
Get feedback on structure, plot, character development, market potential and more, helping you strengthen your concept and move into the drafting process with confidence.
What kinds of publishers will you approach?
As agents we understand that authors’ minds immediately jump to the book’s cover and the logo on the spine: my thoughts would do, too! It’s totally fair to ask this, and also to ask about the types of publisher – will they mix things up, approaching ‘big’ publishers and indies in the same round of submissions? Each type of publisher has its own merit, and this will open up the conversation to the submissions process from the agent to the publisher and how the agent approaches this in rounds (or otherwise).
The agent should, and I’m sure will, also be asking you questions, about how you write – whether you find deadlines useful, for instance – and what you as an author are looking for in an agent.
I’d ask the agent: how do you like to work?
The call is very much to understand what the agent will do and what they want from you, but it’s also hugely constructive for the agent to be able to tell the author how they work – and again, this could open up a whole other side to the conversation on the publishing process.
Lastly, again: were I an author, I’d want to know – what happens if this doesn’t work out as hoped? What if my book doesn’t sell?
As an agent, I’d welcome this question, but I don’t think it’s fair for me to speak for others – this might be something you can just feel around asking on the call.
You’d hope to hear: I believe in you and your writing, so we keep going until we get there.
The agent-author relationship is a unique relationship – it’s professional, but also very personal and tied in with the author’s hopes and ideals for their work. In all of this, for me the most important thing to start things off with is good and open communication.
So: ask away!
Want to ask an agent your questions directly? Come along to our monthly Q&As in Premium Membership or for more personalised feedback, consider booking an Agent One-to-One session for a fifteen-minute phone call directly based on your submission pack.